« Random Is The New Black | Main | The internet is not your friend (for a moment) »

Feb 05, 2008

Comments

Vicki Brown

That's horrendous! It's probably some junior had a 'great idea' and no-one else in the in-house office likes NIN so wouldn't have clicked. It's so difficult to do anything about it though - the company I work for has a major copyright problem at the moment and there's pretty much nothing you can do. All you can really do is carry on being fresher and better and leave them behind, looking tired.

W&W

Happens a lot more than you think I would imagine. Lazy designers flicking through design books with a deadline to meet.

Look what Paul Frank Industries did to a poster designed by Trickett & Webb.

https://tiny.cc/dbluk

Mat

(@ Vicki)

I absolutely agree. You can also 'spread the word' around the design industry (and given the source the work - around the music industry too) so people are actually aware of what's happened. If McDonald's don't pay the price financially they will at least be known for plagiarising and thinking its OK.

Whether that will disuade people from buying Big Macs is another conversation though.

Loïc

>Vicki Brown: "some junior"? why can't seniors be lazy motherfuckers too?

Ryan Y.

This is obviously terrible and Im not condoning it but for the sake of debate...


Q. Would you rather look at some terrible original graphics while you eat your soggy burger? or At some half-decent copied graphics?

In a perfect world the best of both would be nice and should be the norm.

Steve O

Saw this a few months ago. The cut in half logo is the real giveaway. It does happen all the time though - in my workplace for one much to my annoyance. I thought the Sony Bravia / Kozyndan saga was a much worse public ripoff. A few months after Kozyndan are asked to submit work, Passion produce the advert and deny anyone there had ever seen the work? Come on...

Joe Clark

David Carson, nobody’s sentimental favourite, might not own the copyright to the allegedly-infringed images.

John T

I'm not condoning what the guy did, but honestly, Carson has been imitated so much over the past 15 years, I'm not sure this is any different than any other time. I don't think he can do anything about it. (Not to mention that anytime one uses stock art, they run the risk someone else will use the same image.) What about the guy/gal that first came up with the multi-flower-embellished silhouette element? That person should sue every graphic designer in the country.

Rob Mortimer

Looks a clear copy, but is it any more a copy than other things we see everyday.

Florian

Indeed a copy.

vos broekema

Both David Carson and McDonalds suck, so what's the problem?

sayerazifohnas

hahaha.... this is the work of a person who wants to get things done quick.. just like ordering mcdonalds..

quick..

lol !

Maynard Winter

John T: I've never used the multi-flower embellished silhouette element.

Vos: How many books on graphic design have you written?

Guest

The typeface and spacing for "easy natural" are very similar to those of "the fragile" as well. It's an obvious rip. Something I'd expect from a lazy design student, but never in (as you say) designs for a large corporation appearing worldwide.

mark topper

I doubt Mr. Carson took the flower photos. The photographer is who should be taking legal action. You can't very well sue for stealing design ideas- happens all of the time, but not crediting the photographer is is the issue in this situation. Additionally, I sure hope Mr. Carson had permission to use the photos in the first place... I hear there has been trouble for him with that in the past.

lee

actually your flower doubt is quite wrong.
if you look at mr carsons last book trek,
youll see he took ALL the photos for the fragile
cd packaging. and he copyrighted them.
get clued in and stay tuned.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Your Information

(Name is required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)